“No photographer is as good as the simplest camera.”
I am in Patagonia (Argentina) for 10 days. I debated taking the Canon 5Dii, but decided not to bring it because it would be a tempting target for thieves. Instead I opted for taking a Point & Shoot (P&S). Below are my pro and cons around using a Point & Shoot.
Reasons I don’t like a point and shoot
- No tripod – a tripod would have helped, even in the wind I could hold it down
- No polarizing filter; the sky has big beautiful puffy clouds that just are not coming out
- More resolution; to allow for cropping
- Sharper lens. There is a distinct curvature in the P&S images that is annoying. Lightroom lens correction helps, but it is not enough. (see the image of lake Traful, Argentina)
- Can’t hand hold something that light in the wind steady. Yes, I could/should bring a tripod and put a plate on the Point and shoot, but the tripod ball head is practically as big as the P&S. A tripod by itself would have done nothing given the high winds that were blowing us people around. However, putting my weight on the tripod would have done better than me swaying in the 40 mph winds.
- Lower dynamic range (see waterfall photo). This is particularly an issue when traveling when it is harder to get the morning and evening hours of low light that decrease the contrast. HDR helps, but it is not enough to compensate for the very high contrast environments.
- Have to have higher ISO with more noise to account for the hand held aspect.
Reasons for using a P&S
- Less likely to be mugged when travelling abroad because of big expensive camera. This was the primary reason for bringing the P&S versus the Canon big glass. If it is stolen, then less loss.
- It is lighter and easier to use (not true) when traveling. Yes it is lighter, and smaller which is a big plus. But in the wind, and for the shots I want, it did not produce them.
- Why take a tripod for a P&S (oh how foolish am I).
- With a tripod it is easier to take exposure bracketed frames to increase dynamic range.
- Not have as blurry a photo.
- Use a lower ISO that has better noise characteristics.
So the conclusion is….
I need a new small, doesn’t look like big glass, lighter solution. So, for the price of a single big glass lens I can get a body and lens. I got a Sony Nex 6,